BlogU

  • Dad

    By Dean Dad April 19, 2009 8:38 pm

    My Dad died Friday. He was 69.

    He was at home. He had battled ALS – Lou Gehrig's disease – for the last several years, and had been in hospice for several months.

    The last time I saw him was a few months ago. I had brought a camera with me, but when I saw him, realized that using it would be wrong. He deserved better than to be remembered that way.

    He knew it was coming. At the last visit, he made a point of showing me a pile of old family photos, and inviting me to take the ones I wanted. I took several from back when he and Mom were still married.

    Toward the end, the blog was the major way he kept up with me, since he had lost intelligible speech to the disease. The last time we tried to talk on the phone, his wife had to put me on speaker, and she translated him for me as best she could. This for a man who once had a voice so rich and gentle that he did public service announcements on a local radio station. Until the disease took speech from him, he never really lost the Tennessee accent, despite living almost fifty years in the Northeast.

    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


    When I think of him, though, I don't really think of the last thirty years or so. I think of my first ten, when he was still around a lot, and before the tensions grew. I'm older now than he was then, which seems both obvious and inconceivable.

    I remember wrestling with him in the front yard once, laughing as I flipped over his back. He seemed impossibly large, though he wasn't. He took my brother and me to see the local minor league teams play. He thought of himself as a gifted photographer, for reasons known only to him, and I remember him posing us for all kinds of ridiculous shots. In the very early years, I have clear memories of him dancing with Mom in the family room to the Fifth Dimension on the record player. I remember hearing the electric typewriter at night from the dining room while I was trying to fall asleep upstairs.

    He was once a night owl, and he always snored like a champion, so he frequently fell asleep almost as soon as he sat down. It used to drive Mom nuts. I once pranked him by putting my Batman talking alarm clock behind the easy chair as he slept, and setting it off. I thought I'd be in trouble, but Mom enjoyed it more than I did.

    He took me on several ill-fated camping trips with the cub scouts. I'm not sure which of us hated them more. We could make it rain just by camping.

    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


    I remember vividly the day they told us they were divorcing. I can describe where everybody sat. It was the summer before I turned 11. I wasn't much older than TB is now. My brother wasn't much older than TG is now. He told me once that he has no memory of them together.


    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    The years after that were harder. I was the latchkey older kid, so I had to watch my brother until Mom got home. They both remarried, her briefly and him permanently. All that change, plus the usual nerd-goes-through-adolescence stuff, made for a bumpy ride. Sometimes I was able to be reasonably decent about it, and sometimes not. We did the 'joint custody' thing, which is tough in the teen years when you'd really rather be with your friends. To this day, I get a little weird sometimes around packing.

    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


    Dad meant well, but some things just weren't in him. He could be courtly, and I don't know if I ever heard him raise his voice. But there was a defeatism in him that could drive me to distraction. There's a brilliant scene in the movie Parenthood where Steve Martin imagines his adult son in a clock tower, shooting at a crowd. Steve Martin grabs the megaphone from the cop to try to talk his son down, and the son shoots it out of his hand. Trying to be encouraging, he yells “good shot, son!” That was Dad. He was maddeningly quick to assume the worst, and to accept it. And the whole “understanding the other person's point of view” thing just didn't take, somehow. Some of the blind spots were so ridiculous that it was hard not to assume malice. But it wasn't malice. He was just blind to some things that most of us consider basic, like grandchildren. The abrupt bull-in-a-china-shop cluelessness never seemed to fit with the gentle and courtly manner. He was always nice to whomever happened to be in the room at the time.


    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Now he's gone, and I'm a father. TB and TG barely knew him. Much of what I try to do as a father is defined, in part, by awareness of what he did. Having seen the 'divorced dad' thing up close, I want no part of it. And while God knows I've got my flaws and my blind spots, defeatism is not one of them. I will not teach my kids to settle. To deal, yes. To settle, no. There's a difference.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Now he's gone. And for all the ways he left me perplexed at some of the things he did, he was my Dad. He did what he was capable of, and some of it was very, very good. He was once the gentle giant who sat with my Mom on the front porch on a warm night, his hand on her back as they watched the sun set. Maybe nobody else remembers seeing that, but I remember.

Advertisement

Comments on Dad

  • Posted by Susan Weston on April 20, 2009 at 4:30am EDT
  • Thank you for sharing such a thoughtful reflection on a complex relationship, showing a child's love, an adult's frustration, and an adult's love all at once. And a stranger's condolences on your loss.

  • Posted by robinsonraj , Hi at s.v.k.polytechnic on April 20, 2009 at 6:45am EDT
  • Hi,

    This is a wonderful opinion. The things mentioned are unanimous and needs to be appreciated by everyone.

    robinson

  • Thank you
  • Posted by ezry on April 20, 2009 at 7:45am EDT
  • Now I, too, can remember your dad, who could make it rain just by camping. Through you, he continues to touch people like me. Thank you.

  • Thanks
  • Posted by RJS , Executive Assistant to the President at Bethel University on April 20, 2009 at 8:15am EDT
  • There is almost nothing harder to write about than the death of a parent. Thanks for the sharp, particular vision you brought to this, that does not omit how you feel, and does not neglect how you've resolved to be different.

    I've always enjoyed your work, and this adds a new depth to the "you" I enjoy.

  • Posted by Thomas on April 20, 2009 at 8:30am EDT
  • Perfect note. Thank you for sharing, it meant a lot to me.

  • Posted by Oronte on April 20, 2009 at 9:00am EDT
  • Sorry about your dad, CCD. May we all be remembered lovingly.

  • Posted by Mike , Asst professor English at St Louis CC on April 20, 2009 at 9:30am EDT
  • I lost my dad when he turned 69, too--no matter how old they--or we--are, parents are tough to lose. And tough to write about. Your post is a wonderful example of how to pay homage. Thanks very much.

  • Dad
  • Posted by Jeffrey on April 20, 2009 at 11:15am EDT
  • Thanks for this. I follow your blog regularly and enjoy your posts. Makes me think of my own father, who's 80, with all his flaws. And me, a divorded-remarried father with a joint custody arrangement (which is better than what was, believe me). I also think of Russo's Straight Man and the father-son relationship there as well as the Updike story on the divorce ("Separating" I think). Anyway, blessing to you and your family.

  • My condolences
  • Posted by JCL on April 20, 2009 at 11:15am EDT
  • I too lost my father to ALS in January of 2004; he was 61. Thanks for sharing a little bit about your father and family. Your words bring to mind many memories, both bitter and sweet. Thanks.

  • Beautiful recollection
  • Posted by Howie , Director of Communications at www.cookross.typepad.com on April 20, 2009 at 11:15am EDT
  • Thank you for sharing your love and your struggles to accept your dad's inability to consistently meet your expectations. I struggle with that myself. I empathize with your enduring hurt over your parents' divorce. Please continue to share your humanity along with your wisdom via your blog.

  • Your Dad Sounds a Lot Like Mine
  • Posted by Eric Gates , Sr. Sales Consultant at ALEKS Corporation on April 20, 2009 at 11:45am EDT
  • Dean Dad,

    I am sorry for your loss, and touched by your typically subtle, honest, complex approach to your Dad's passing.

    You could have been writing about my childhood, and my feelings when my own father died at 64.

    Thank you.

  • Condolences & thx for great post
  • Posted by Mark on April 20, 2009 at 11:45am EDT
  • Discovered your blog thru subscribing to IHE online a few months ago and appreciate what you write about the profession. That said, this is a powerful post - thanks for sharing it. Am a divorced Dad who's trying hard to make that work & struggle more w/ how to relate to my own father the older I get (approaching 50). Your thoughts are a powerful reminder of not just living in the moment and the current realities of family life but remembering what counted in the past and the key roles our parents played in getting us here. Generally, that includes good and bad lessons.

    Sympathies to you and your family on the loss.

  • Remember the good things
  • Posted by Terri , Education at MSMC on April 20, 2009 at 12:15pm EDT
  • Human beings have flaws. The parents we are delivered into have done the best they could under the circumstances they have had to live with. There are no perfect parents. Focus on the wonderful things that happened in your life, appreciate who you are as a direct result of your father's influence, good or bad. Remember that 50% of children grow up in single parent families and do not have any memories of a "Dad". Resolve to be the kind of parent that your own children and grandchildren will remember fondly one day. And pray, that someday you too, do not divorce because staying together for the sake of the children is one of the hardest sacrifices to make in a lifetime that comes to an end all too quickly.

  • Posted by Diane on April 20, 2009 at 12:45pm EDT
  • This is a beautiful tribute. Thank you for sharing it. 

  • Posted by CMK on April 20, 2009 at 2:00pm EDT
  • I'm so sorry for your loss. Thank you for sharing these really poignant memories while also reflecting on the complicated parent/child relationship.

  • Divorce and Death
  • Posted by LH on April 20, 2009 at 3:00pm EDT
  • My folks divorced when I was 13 and, like Dean Dad, I remember quite clearly the scene when my mother told me it was going to happen and the world as I knew it was turned upside down. This was in 1958, when there was a layer of shame on top of all the other feelings. My relationship with my father was always distant, but it was at its best from his age 90 to 93 when he died. I reached out a bit, and he had mellowed.

    ALS strikes me as a particularly ghastly way to lose somebody, especially one who is relatively young.

    Best wishes in this tough time.

  • Posted by Seth , Student at Monroe CC on April 20, 2009 at 9:15pm EDT
  • Dean Dad,

    You have my deepest sympathy on the passing of your father. He sounds like he was a good and decent man, who always tried to do the right thing. May he find peace and yourself and loved ones, joy in celebrating his life.

  • Father-Son Relationships
  • Posted by First Born on April 21, 2009 at 10:45am EDT
  • Condolences, Dean Dad. Always enjoy your insights.

    Father and son relationships are awfully complicated.

    They are with my dad; they are with my sons.